Ubuntu 22.04 SSH-RSA Login Failure

Debugging public-key auth failures on Ubuntu 22.04 after ssh-rsa was disabled by default; covers root cause and three fixes.

Jul 18, 2022 · 2 min read · 240 Words · -Views -Comments · Programming
Linux WebShell 🇨🇳 阅读中文版
Read with AI

Choose an AI assistant

ChatGPT Open in a new tab with the article link and prompt
Claude Copy the prompt, then open Claude

Open Claude
Trouble reading the article?

If the prompt is missing, copy the full prompt below into your AI assistant. If the AI cannot read the article, paste the visible passage you want to discuss and add your question.

Users reported that our WebShell couldn’t log into Ubuntu 22.04 via SSH key—authentication kept failing. Here’s the investigation and fix.

error screenshot

ssh2 (the Node.js library we use) reported:

Client: publickey auth failed
Error: All configured authentication methods failed

Investigation

  1. Keys were RSA.
  2. Logging in via Terminal/iTerm2 on macOS worked:
    ssh -v -i ~/test.pem ubuntu@1.221.54.8
    
    So our WebShell implementation (ssh2) was the outlier.

Tip: If you see Permissions 0644 for 'test.pem' are too open, run chmod 400 test.pem. Type exit to close the session.

Analysis

  • Both Terminal and iTerm2 succeed; apps built on the ssh2 module (Tabby, Electerm, etc.) fail. So the issue is in ssh2.
  • Ubuntu 22.04 disables ssh-rsa signatures by default; older releases didn’t.

Conclusion: new OpenSSH servers reject SHA-1 signatures, while ssh2 still tries to use them. Local terminals handle the fallback; ssh2 doesn’t (yet).

Fixes

  1. Server configuration — allow ssh-rsa temporarily:
    sudo vi /etc/ssh/sshd_config
    PubkeyAcceptedKeyTypes +ssh-rsa
    sudo service sshd restart
    
  2. Regenerate keys with stronger algorithms (e.g., ed25519).
  3. Upgrade ssh2 — use a commit/PR that adds rsa-sha2-512/256 support:
    "ssh2": "git@github.com:Eugeny/ssh2.git#22735cecf1d9c118b2b8af1c2f80fe5b04996fe1"
    

All three solutions work.

Why ssh-rsa Is Deprecated

From OpenSSH 8.2 release notes:

Chosen-prefix attacks against SHA-1 now cost < $50K. We’ll disable the ssh-rsa signature algorithm by default in a future release.

RSA itself is fine; SHA-1 is weak. Ubuntu 22.04 prefers rsa-sha2-512/256. ssh2 failed because it kept signing with SHA-1. Update: https://github.com/Eugeny/ssh2/commit/22735cec

Final Thoughts

Existing RSA keys are still usable—just avoid SHA-1 signatures.

References

Authors
Developer, digital product enthusiast, tinkerer, sharer, open source lover