redux-logger Tree Shaking Not Working

Investigates why redux-logger stays in production bundles, explores its UMD build, tries the 4.x ES module beta, and confirms tree-shaking once sideEffects is set.

Sep 14, 2024 · 1 min read · 195 Words · -Views -Comments · Programming
Redux Webpack Tree Shaking 🇨🇳 阅读中文版
Read with AI

Choose an AI assistant

ChatGPT Open in a new tab with the article link and prompt
Claude Copy the prompt, then open Claude

Open Claude
Trouble reading the article?

If the prompt is missing, copy the full prompt below into your AI assistant. If the AI cannot read the article, paste the visible passage you want to discuss and add your question.

Issue

Even in Webpack production builds, redux-logger sticks around. Since the logger is only needed in development, it should disappear. Let’s see why it doesn’t.

https://static.1991421.cn/2024/2024-09-14-152754.jpeg

Project Setup

"redux-logger": "^3.0.6"

Usage:

import { createLogger } from 'redux-logger';

const logMiddlewares = process.env.NODE_ENV === 'development'
  ? [createLogger({ collapsed: true })]
  : [];

const middleWares = [...logMiddlewares];

const store = createStore(
  createRootReducer,
  compose(applyMiddleware(...middleWares))
);

Looking into redux-logger

  1. "main": "dist/redux-logger.js" points at the distribution build. That’s fine—main can reference either CommonJS or ES modules.
  2. dist/redux-logger.js is a UMD bundle that works in CommonJS and AMD environments. Webpack cannot tree-shake UMD output.

https://static.1991421.cn/2024/2024-09-14-153225.jpeg

Given the UMD build, it’s expected that tree shaking fails.

Trying redux-logger 4.0 Beta

"redux-logger": "4.0.0"

A beta release on npm ships ES modules, so I tried upgrading. Packaging still retained the logger because tree shaking also requires the sideEffects flag.

On the plus side, the import now resolves to an ES module:

https://static.1991421.cn/2024/2024-09-14-153328.jpeg

Bundle size at this stage:

https://static.1991421.cn/2024/2024-09-14-153350.jpeg

Adding sideEffects

To confirm the fix, I republished the package with "sideEffects": false in package.json, then analyzed the build again.

https://static.1991421.cn/2024/2024-09-14-153416.jpeg

"redux-logger": "npm:@stacker/redux-logger@4.0.1"

https://static.1991421.cn/2024/2024-09-14-153451.jpeg

Final Result

With an ES module build and sideEffects declared, Webpack finally drops redux-logger from production bundles.

Reference

Authors
Developer, digital product enthusiast, tinkerer, sharer, open source lover